Abstract:
Construction industry in Ethiopia is growing fast, but also has problems like time overrun, cost
overrun and productivity problems in many of the projects. In construction projects the resources
used in construction phase of each activity are the key factors that determine the total project
cost and time. Among these labor productivity is vital for overall productivity and success of a
project especially for developing countries like Ethiopia, where most of the building activities
are performed by a huge amount of labors or it is labor intensive. In order to improve these labor
productivity, it has to be measured and standardized properly. Due to this reason Ministry of
Urban Development and Housing prepared a document entitled building construction output
norms in Ethiopia in 1995 aimed at assisting and providing information and data needed for
those involved in the construction industry. However, these output norms were not taken from
actual site measurement and it is being used in current construction industry. The objective of
this research is comparing the actual man-hour values and the Ministry of Urban Development
and Housing’s theoretical man-hour values, to rank activities with high difference when their
actual and theoretical man-hour values are compared, determining productivity baseline by using
Thomas’s and clustering baseline approaches for 20cm HCB work, 3 coats of plastic paint,
60cm*60cm ceramic tile, two coats of plastering and super structure concrete work ,assessing
current practice of using these norms by public building projects in Bahir Dar, and showing the
gap between the theoretical man hour norm set by Ministry of Urban Development and Housing
and actually registered man hour values of labor productivity in public building construction
projects in Bahir Dar. Data were collected from both primary and secondary sources. The
primary data were obtained through work sampling technique, actual site visit, questionnaire and
interview. The secondary data were obtained from previously done different researches, internet
sources, journals, books, reports and various articles. The finding from questionnaires showed
that almost all public buildings in Bahir Dar are using theoretical man-hour value by Ministry of
Urban Development and Housing for tendering, scheduling and planning, estimation of project
cost and time and for controlling and monitoring purposes. Labor intensive and common civil
works were listed and let the respondents to give the degree of differences compared with the
norm (very low difference, low difference, moderate, high difference and very high difference).
By their scored Relative Importance Index value the top ten activities were selected to detail
iii
comparison by measuring their actual man-hour productivity measurements. After ranking the
activities the researcher selected the top 10 activities and actual site measurement was taken for
15 working days. However, the only 5 activities were on progress i.e. 20cm HCB work, 3 coats
of plastic paint, 60cm*60cm ceramic tile, two coats of plastering and super structure concrete
work on the time of data measurement; whereas back filling work, trench excavation work, 50cm
stone masonry above natural ground level, Sub structure concrete work and 5cm cement screed
were not active on that time. After getting hourly productivity output their actual productivity
baseline value were determined. The actual productivity for selected work items ( 20cm HCB
work, three coats of plastic paint, 60cm*60cm ceramic floor tile, two coats of cement mortar
plastering and super structure c-25 concrete) were: for 20cm HCB work = 1.4m
2
/hr, for three
coats of plastic paint work = 3.125 m
2
/hr, for 60cm*60cm ceramic floor tile work = 2.05 m
2
/hr,
for two coats of cement mortar plastering = 1.85 m
2
/hr and for Super structure concrete work =
2.96 m
3
/hr. One sample t-test SPSS software to was used to decide whether It is essential to
revise the norm or not. The p values of all analyzed five activities by one sample t-test were less
than 0.05. The result revealed that there are significant differences between Ministry Of Works
and Urban Development Norm and actual man hour productivity value. Therefore, updating
these man-hour values is important.
Key words; Building, Construction, Labor, Man-hour productivity, Norm, Schedule