Abstract:
Selecting the appropriate contractor is a significant step to building project success. The
correct selection of a competent and suitable contractor may have a positive impact on
the outcomes of the works and result in the successful completion of construction
projects in time, within budget and with better quality. However, in Ethiopia, the
selection of the contractor for a construction project is subjected to uncertainty and
influence of criteria other than bid price and thus the results are not completel y
consistent. To fill this gap on the problem of contractor selection, this thesis aims to
develop a building contractor selection decision making model using an analytical
network process. The paper also explains the procedures conducted to formulate a
computational model (mathematical model) that can be used to select the most suitable
applicant and prioritize competitive contractors for building projects. To achieve these
objectives, mixed (qualitative and quantitative) surveys as a research design, purposive
sampling as a sampling technique, and both primary and secondary data as a source of
data were used. For the primary data, the researcher has used an online questionnaire and
interview and for the secondary data document reviews were employed. Among the
surveyed, 19 out of 34 (55.88%) respondents (contractors, consultants, clients, and
academicians) gave responses. The data gathered was analyzed using Analytical Network
Process (ANP). In an Analytical Network Process (ANP) technique, first different
selection criteria were identified and grouped into major criteria. The major criteria were
weighted and a decision support model was developed and the validity of the developed
model was tested in a real project (Case Study). Finally, the results were presented using
tables, frequencies, and percentages. It was determined that using the lowest bid value as
a sole criterion for selecting the best contractors may not result in an optimum solution.
Key words: Analytic network process, analytic hierarchy process, multi-criteria
decision- making, contractor selection.